Sunday, February 21, 2010

1.9 Comparing Theories of Creation and Evolution

The previous sections have discussed several different varieties of creationist theories and several different evolutionary theories from the natural sciences. Each one proposes or implies a variety of scientific evidence and philosophical rationale for its position. How are we to evaluate these various theories and compare between them?

This section illustrates and compare these various theories in several different ways. One method of comparing them is to look at what aspects of science (including various forms of evolution) are accepted by the different creation science theories, and which aspects are rejected. Then one can compare the relative strength of the scientific evidence.


<1800 YEC OEC TE
MicroevolutionNoYesYesYes
Age of earth > 4 b.y.NoNoYesYes
Stellar EvolutionNo?YesYes
Age of universe > 13 b.y. NoNoYesYes
MacroevolutionNoNoNoYes
Chemical EvolutionNoNoNo?

None of the above points accepted by modern science were in wide acceptance before the year 1800, because the evidence had not yet been widely studied. Most advocates of creation science in all modern varieties are willing to accept evidence of microevolution (small changes within species), where it was once thought that species were individually created by God and were fixed and unchanging. Old Earth Creation is willing to accept the age of the earth and the universe and its development over time, but is unwilling to accept macroevolution. Theistic Evolution accepts all of these (with the provision that God is in indirect control of all these things), but is split over whether the first development of life (chemical evolution) could have happened through explainable natural forces, or whether this is an example of where God’s direct supernatural intervention was required. Intelligent Design is not included in this table, because ID advocates do not claim to take a position on these issues.

A different form of this comparison is found at Craig Rusbilt’s page “Definitions and Comparisons in Logical Scientific Evaluation of Evolution and Creation) (http://www.asa3.org/ASA/education/origins/logic.htm).

Wednesday, June 3, 2009

1.8.4 Microevolution and Macroevolution

Microevolution and Macroevolution

Within the subject of biological evolution, the terms “microevolution” and “macroevolution” are used. Microevolution is used to refer to those small changes that occur over generations, generally within a given species or sub-species. Macroevolution usually refers to the large-scale changes between major groups, such as plants and animals, amphibians and mammals, etc.

It used to be believed that since God created all things to reproduce “after their kind,” all species must remain unchanged after their appearance on the earth. This idea was based on the philosophies of Plato and Aristotle, and the work of Carolus Linnaeus in the 18th century. Linnaeus was the one who provided the basis for biological classification into such groupings as kingdom, phylum, class, order, family, genus, and species.

It is now well accepted even by most creation scientists that organisms do undergo genetic mutation, adaptation, and speciation (dividing into new species or sub-species). These kinds of changes can actually be observed over relatively short periods of time. However, most creation science advocates hold that such changes are limited to the species level, or to a more vague grouping of a Biblical “kind” that possibly includes the scientific classification of genus, or even “family.” Sometimes they will use another term such as “adaptation” to avoid the dreaded “E” word.

One of the problems with creation scientists saying that “microevolution within kinds has occurred, but macroevolution hasn’t” is the fact that their categories of “kinds” are not well defined. They may allow in some cases that a “kind” includes genus as well as species. Thus, “microevolution” within a “kind” might take in quite a lot of biological change, and yet must necessarily fall short of being macroevolution, because they have created their own unique definitions to be mutually exclusive. What it seems to come down to for many creation science advocates is that “microevolution is any sort of biological evolution that I am willing to accept, and macroevolution is any evolution that I am unwilling to accept.”

Macroevolution, or changes from one major group of organisms to another, is much more difficult to observe directly, because it presumably takes vastly longer periods of time to accomplish. Much of the evidence for macroevolution comes from comparison of fossil evidence of growing diversity of species over time, and the observable features and genetic relatedness between various groups of organisms. One of the really bad arguments made by creation scientists involves a confusion or distortion over what macroevolution really means. Caricatures or cartoons of hippos giving birth to whales may be comical, but as an attack on the scientific arguments for macroevolution, they fall far short. Scientists don’t believe, for instance, that some crocodile gave birth to the first bird. Rather, they say that reptiles and birds share a “common ancestor” at approximately some geological epoch, and that successive changes brought about diversity between the two lineages until distinct species developed.

Scientists in the field of biology, if they do use the distinction of micro- and macroevolution, generally believe that they are part of the same thing, and that there is no clear distinction between micro- and macroevolution. They observe that small changes occur within the species. They observe evidence for one species dividing into two distinct species, which can no longer mate with each other. They see other evidences of change over time in physical characteristics, genetics, and fossil progression through the geological record, and they conclude that macroevolution is simply microevolution that has been at work for a very long time. Some of these issues will be discussed later, but suffice it to say there are evidences for macroevolution having actually occurred (see “29+ Evidences for Macroevolution”, by Douglas Theobald). Whether such evidence is convincing or the conclusions are justified is certainly a matter for debate.

Sunday, May 31, 2009

1.8.3 Biological evolution, Darwinism and Neo-Darwinism

Biological evolution is the theory that all existing species of plant and animal have developed from common ancestors. It has to do with the survival and adaptation of existing biological forms of life, and is thus distinct from other varieties of evolution, such as stellar or chemical evolution. It is also the one which receives the most popular attention and controversy.

Charles Darwin’s book On the Origin of Species is most commonly credited with the development of the “theory of evolution,” based on his observations of geology and the variety of species, but there were others around the same time proposing similar theories (such as Alfred Russel Wallace). Previous to Darwin’s time, a common view was that all of nature was specially designed for specific purposes, and biological species were thought to remain unchanged as originally created. Darwin suggested that organisms change over time, branching out from a common ancestor (“descent with modification”), and that competitive pressures will lead to the survival of organisms that can pass on traits which make their continued survival more likely (“natural selection”). Thus, biological evolution is sometimes referred to as “Darwinism”.
However, at the time Darwin wrote, neither he nor anyone else had knowledge of genetics (later discovered by Mendel and others), DNA, and a variety of other mechanisms which have since been discovered in biological organisms. Darwin himself proposed that parent species acquired new observable traits during their lifetimes which were passed on to their descendents (later termed “Lamarckism”, which has since fallen out of favor in the scientific community). The modern scientific theory of evolution is sometimes referred to as “neo-Darwinism”, because it retains the original ideas of Charles Darwin, but has been modified and synthesized with other theories.

Darwin’s theories of natural selection and common descent are central to current biological theory, but in many ways the modern synthesis of evolutionary theory is different from Charles Darwin’s original writings. Most scientific publications don’t generally use the term “Darwinism.” The term seems mostly to be used by creationist organizations in their rhetoric against “the godless, atheistic alternative to the Biblical creation account.” They are describing a philosophy rather than a strictly scientific account of nature. For these reasons, the term “Darwinism” is fairly useless today for describing the current scientific theory of biological evolution, because it means vastly different things to different people.

It should also be noted that even though some people credit Charles Darwin with striking a fatal blow against religious belief and promoting merely blind chance in place of divine providence, Darwin’s theory did not exclude the influence of a divine Creator. Even though he personally went through periods of theism, deism, and ended up an agnostic, he was never an atheist. His view of nature always acknowledged some sort of belief in intelligent design, as he could not bring himself to think of the wonderful complexities of nature occurring completely on their own (http://www.ualberta.ca/~dlamoure/3Darwin.htm). In the sixth edition of On the Origin of Species, the phrase “by the Creator” was added to the final paragraph: “There is grandeur in this view of life, with its several powers, having been originally breathed by the Creator into a few forms or into one; and that, whilst this planet has gone cycling on according to the fixed law of gravity, from so simple a beginning endless forms most beautiful and most wonderful have been, and are being, evolved.”

Saturday, May 30, 2009

1.8.2 Chemical Evolution

Chemical evolution has to do abiogenesis (“origin of life”). It involves scientific hypotheses for how the first living things might have been able to form from the right combination of chemicals and other factors. Experiments, such as one conducted by Stanley Miller and Harold Ulrey in 1952, show that organic compounds, including amino acids, can form spontaneously from the right combination of chemicals and energy. It is speculated that this might have been one means of forming the precursors to the first living things on earth.

There are a number of problems with the scientific data on this, including the fact that such molecules found in nature are either all “left handed” or “right handed,” but those formed spontaneously in the experiments contain an equal number of both, which is not suitable for life as we know it. It is also unknown what combination of chemicals were present in the earth’s early atmosphere, and whether the precise environmental conditions were present to allow them to form spontaneously. Many scientific theories abound, which attempt to explain these questions, but so far there is no definitive model which can explain the pathway from inorganic chemicals to self-replicating molecules, not to mention complex living cells, etc.

Monday, April 6, 2009

1.8.1 Stellar Evolution

Stellar evolution

Stellar evolution describes a scientific theory of how stars, elements, and galaxies could form spontaneously as a result of the Big Bang, using known physical laws of gravitation and nuclear forces. The theory comes from observing stars at many different stages of existence and comparing with the results of theoretical simulations made by computer models.

The current scientific paradigm for the origin and development of the early universe is the Big Bang theory. This states that the universe originated approximately 13.7 billion years ago from an extremely hot, extremely dense point of extremely small volume. From that point, matter and energy emanated into space – actually, theory says that space itself expanded from that point to become the known visible universe. Slight fluctuations in gravity caused atoms to clump together, eventually forming clusters of matter that would eventually become bonded together by the force of gravitation.
This cloud eventually collapses, releasing heat and condensing into a sphere of superheated gas. The gas reaches the point where nuclear fusion begins, and protons fuse together to form hydrogen, deuterium and helium. A new star is born.

Depending on the size and mass of the star, it may go through various stages of development. The process of fusion continues, creating heavier elements with more protons. At a later stage, the core of the star collapses, forming a neutron star, black hole, supernova, and/or white dwarf star. The explosion releases these heavier elements into space, which can recombine later to form new star systems or objects such as planets. Heavier elements may also be released from non-exploding red giant stars.